Technical Activities Committee Web Letter Ballots
Share |

CLOSED BALLOTS

(Record of original votes as of closing date)

Ballot Title/ID: ICRI Technical Committee Manual 2014
Description: The existing TCM and Style Manual have been updated and combined for TAC review and comment. Download the TAC review form in the Document Library and use for comments. Disregard hyperlinks in this review since they are still a work in progress.

Attached File: Background Information
Ballot Type: Letter Ballot
Start Date: 10/15/2014
End Date: 11/12/2014

 


BALLOT ITEMS

Item # Item Description
1 2014 TCM

 

Download all ballot description + item description files as zip file

VOTING MEMBERS:

 

Item # Member Aff. Aff. w/
Editorial
Com.
Neg. Abs. Not
Retd.
Comments Attached
Files
1 *Aamer Syed   X   Comment
Brian Daley     X  
Frank Apicella X   Comment
Fred Goodwin   X   Comment
Gabriel Jimenez X Recommend that the curriculum also include a section on safety (how to read MSDS)and environmental constraints such as noise, dust, disposal, emmissions,etc.
Goodwin, Fred   X additional files sent to J McDonald as described in comments Comment
Jimenez,Gabriel X    
James McDonald   X
John Weisbarth     X Seems like overview and key items should be combined into one outline. This would better serve as a basis for preparation of the educational program content(Tier 1)and identify performance tests required for Tier 2. Also, outline is missing some items/steps that should be considered(ie.NDT methods in addition to soundings and possibly condition survey as separate section). Don't see need for last column of course outline on Page 1 since it applies to all items. Should review potential technical content from all appropriate ICRI guidelines as well as ACI 562, 563, 546, and 364. Lots of follow up work required, including determining consensus on suggested performance testing. Need to discuss if TAC should provide a proposed new outline/direction and whether the certification committee can provide the technical content required to complete this program (or should other ICRI committees be used/consulted?).
Jorge Costa     X Comment
Kenneth Lozen X  
Kevin Michols   X   Comment
Lee Sizemore   X   Comment
Mark Nelson   X   Comment
Peter Kolf   X   Comment
Pierre Hebert   X   Comment
Ralph Jones   X   Comment

 

Download vote and comment files as zip file (Attachments ONLY - Typed in comments cannont be downloaded)

PRELIMINARY VOTING SUMMARY:

There are 14 committee members eligible to vote.

Passage of an item requires resolution of any negative votes. Passage of an item requires that at least 1/2 of all voting members on the committee roster must cast an affirmative vote. Also, the number of affirmative votes must be at least 2/3 of the yes and no votes cast. Please contact ICRI headquarters for additional information on balloting procedures.

Item # Affirmative Affirmative with Editorial Comments Negative Abstain Not Returned The 1/2 Rule The 2/3 Rule
1 9 4 1 1   Item Meets Item Meets

Back to Technical Activities Committee Web Letter Ballots page

Thank You, Supporting Members!

International Concrete Repair Institute

1000 Westgate Drive, Suite 252 | St. Paul, Minnesota 55114 USA | Phone: +1 651-366-6095

©2016 International Concrete Repair Institute, Inc.

Privacy Policy